Thursday, January 16, 2025

Canary in the Labor Market

The latest economic signals are impossible to ignore. Data on the labor market, retail sales, and consumer spending point to a troubling reality: the foundations of the U.S. economy are weakening. While headline narratives cling to fragile optimism, the underlying numbers tell a different story, one of slowing growth and mounting vulnerabilities. 

Unemployment data, when stripped of seasonal adjustments, reveals alarming trends. Initial jobless claims surged to 351,000, a sharp jump from 306,000 the week prior. Continued claims reached 2.28 million, climbing by over 93,000. These are not seasonal fluctuations; they are the symptoms of a labor market that can no longer absorb displaced workers. 

Seasonal workers, laid off after the holidays, face a sobering reality... the jobs they once relied on are not simply coming back. This is particularly troubling as continued unemployment claims historically indicate a prolonged slowdown in hiring and consumer spending. 

Retailers reported an underwhelming holiday season, with inflation-adjusted retail sales barely scraping positive territory at just 1.27% year-over-year. This modest bump was not a sign of consumer strength but rather a reflection of shoppers front-running anticipated price hikes from looming tariffs. 

Target, a bellwether for retail performance, reported a 2% increase in comparable sales for November and December. However, with inflation running at 2.9%, this represents a real decline in purchasing power. The data exposes a larger issue: consumers are retreating from discretionary spending. Key categories like home goods, long a Target stronghold, have weakened significantly. 

The narrative that wage growth outpaces inflation is increasingly detached from reality. Average hourly earnings for nonsupervisory employees rose by just 1% year-over-year, falling far short of inflation and signaling a real decline in disposable income.

Historical parallels provide a stark warning. In both the dot-com bubble and the Global Financial Crisis, wages temporarily outpaced inflation before recessions took hold. Today, the dynamics are eerily similar, with household budgets stretched to the breaking point by rising debt-servicing costs and dwindling savings. 

Hints from Federal Reserve officials suggest rate cuts may be on the table in 2025, but this is no sign of confidence; it’s an acknowledgment of deteriorating conditions. The Fed faces a near-impossible task: managing persistent inflation while responding to cracks in the labor market and slowing consumer demand.

Yet the root problem remains unaddressed. Debt-to-GDP sits at 120%, deficits hover near 7% of GDP, and the Treasury market is increasingly fragile. The Fed’s failure to reduce debt levels during the recent recovery leaves it ill-prepared for the next downturn.

Tariffs, touted as a tool to address trade imbalances, are poised to deliver another economic shock. Retailers are already raising prices to front-run expected cost increases, further straining consumer budgets. Tariffs might address long-term strategic goals, but in the short term, they risk exacerbating inflation and reducing demand. 

The consequences extend far beyond retail. Higher input costs will ripple through supply chains, hitting manufacturers and small businesses. The combination of rising costs, slowing demand, and reduced consumer confidence paints a grim picture for the months ahead. 

The warning signs are unmistakable. Rising unemployment claims, faltering retail sales, and stagnant wage growth reveal an economy on the brink of a broader slowdown. Policymakers’ failure to address structural imbalances during the last decade leaves the U.S. vulnerable to shocks like tariffs, rising interest rates, and declining consumer confidence. 

The cracks are no longer theoretical; they are real, visible, and widening. 


(C) 2025 Chris Barcelo

No comments:

Post a Comment